When we talk about exceptional web design, we often focus on aesthetics, brand alignment, and user experience. However, a truly exceptional design must also be accessible to all users, including those with disabilities. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) extends to digital spaces, making accessibility not just a best practice but a legal requirement for many organizations.
This quick guide explores how designers can create visually compelling websites that are also fully accessible, adhering to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1, which has become the standard for ADA compliance in digital spaces.
Why Accessible Design Matters
Beyond legal compliance, accessible design:
- Expands your audience to include the 61 million Americans with disabilities
- Improves overall user experience for everyone
- Enhances SEO through better structure and content
- Demonstrates corporate social responsibility
- Reduces legal risk in an era of increasing digital accessibility lawsuits
Understanding Disabilities in the Design Context
Effective accessible design addresses the needs of users with various disabilities:
- Visual impairments (including color blindness, low vision, and blindness)
- Hearing impairments
- Motor disabilities
- Cognitive and neurological disabilities
Each presents unique design challenges that require thoughtful solutions.
Essential Design Principles for ADA Compliance
WCAG 2.1 establishes three levels of compliance:
- Level A (Minimum): The most basic level of web accessibility.
- Level AA (Standard): The level most organizations aim for and what is typically referenced in legal contexts.
- Level AAA (Enhanced): The highest level of accessibility, which is often aspirational.
Color and Contrast
Contrast Ratios
WCAG 2.1 AA compliance requires:
- 4.5:1 contrast ratio for normal text
- 3:1 contrast ratio for large text (18pt+ or 14pt+ bold)
Design Action Items:
- Use contrast checker tools during your design process
- Create a palette with accessibility-verified color combinations
- Document minimum contrast requirements in your design system
Color Independence
Never use color alone to convey information or indicate action. An example of this is link decoration on websites, you might see how a hyperlink is displayed as blue, but without underlining the link itself you are excluding a group of people from easily seeing its action.
Design Action Items:
- Add text labels or icons alongside color coding
- Use patterns in addition to colors for charts and graphs
- Test designs in grayscale to ensure they remain usable
Color Blindness Considerations
Approximately 8% of men and 0.5% of women have some form of color blindness.
Design Action Items:
- Avoid problematic color combinations:
- Red/green
- Green/brown
- Blue/purple
- Green/blue
- Test designs with color blindness simulators
- Use higher contrast between colors used for comparison
Typography for Readability
Font Selection
Design Action Items:
- Choose fonts with distinct letterforms (especially for "I," "l," and "1")
- Opt for fonts with adequate apertures (the partially enclosed spaces in letters like 'c' and 'e')
- Ensure fonts render clearly at smaller sizes
- Limit your design to 2-3 font families
Text Styling
Design Action Items:
- Maintain minimum text size (16px for body text is recommended)
- Aim for line heights of at least 1.5 times the font size
- Keep line lengths between 50-75 characters
- Use left-aligned text for improved readability
- Avoid justified text, which can create uneven spacing
- Use adequate spacing between paragraphs
Text in Images
Design Action Items:
- Minimize text embedded in images.
- When text must be in images, ensure it meets the same contrast requirements. This is tricky specifically with responsive websites where the text has multiple positions on the same image. You must check manaually that every part of the text has the proper contrast against the whole image.
- Always provide alt text that includes this embedded text
Layout and Structure
Visual Hierarchy
Design Action Items:
- Create clear visual distinction between headings, subheadings, and body text
- Use consistent styling for similar elements across pages
- Provide visual cues to indicate the relative importance of information
- Design an F-pattern or Z-pattern layout for main content
Spacing and Grouping
Design Action Items:
- Use white space strategically to create logical content groupings
- Design adequate spacing between interactive elements (44px × 44px target size)
- Maintain consistent spacing patterns throughout the design
- Create visual associations between related elements
Responsive Design
Design Action Items:
- Design for multiple breakpoints, ensuring accessibility at all sizes
- Consider how layouts reflow on different devices
- Ensure text remains readable without horizontal scrolling
- Design touch targets that remain accessible on mobile devices
Navigation and Interaction Design
Intuitive Navigation
Design Action Items:
- Design consistent navigation patterns across all pages
- Create clear visual indicators for current location
- Ensure navigation elements are clearly distinguishable
- Provide multiple ways to access important content
Focus States
Design Action Items:
- Design visible, distinctive focus indicators for all interactive elements
- Ensure focus states have sufficient contrast (3:1 minimum)
- Maintain consistent focus styling throughout the site
- Design the focus order to follow a logical progression
Form Design
Design Action Items:
- Create clearly visible form controls with descriptive labels
- Design distinctive states for form elements (focus, error, disabled)
- Group related form fields visually
- Provide clear error states with specific guidance
- Design appropriate input fields for different data types
Images and Media
Alternative Text Planning
Design Action Items:
- Specify when images are decorative vs. informational
- For complex images, plan for detailed descriptions
- For functional images (like buttons), indicate the action
- For charts and graphs, plan for alternative data presentations
Video and Audio Considerations
Design Action Items:
- Design space for captions in video layouts
- Create visually distinctive caption styling
- Plan for transcript placement for audio content
- Design intuitive media player controls
- Rule of thumb is to not set your videos on Auto-Play
Creating Accessible Design Systems
An accessibility-focused design system should include:
Color System
- Primary, secondary, and tertiary palettes with verified contrast ratios
- Documented color combinations for various use cases
- Alternative options for problematic color pairs
Typography System
- Hierarchical type scale with minimum sizes
- Line height and spacing guidelines
- Heading styles with proper visual weight progression
Component Library
- Accessible versions of all UI components
- Documentation of keyboard interaction patterns
- Focus state designs for all interactive elements
- Mobile-friendly touch target sizes
Documentation
- Accessibility rationale for design decisions
- Instructions for implementing accessible features
- Testing protocols for design handoff
Testing Your Designs for Accessibility
Visual Testing
- Color blindness simulation
- Contrast checking
- Text readability at different sizes
- Grayscale testing
Usability Testing
- Keyboard-only navigation testing
- Screen reader testing (in development)
- User testing with people with disabilities
Tools for Accessible Design
Design Tools with Accessibility Features
- Figma with plugins like Stark, Contrast, and A11y
- Adobe XD with accessibility features
- Sketch with accessibility plugins
Evaluation Tools
Designing for Specific Disabilities
Low Vision Users
- Scalable interfaces that function at 200% zoom
- Strong contrast throughout the interface
- Avoidance of absolute positioning that breaks at larger text sizes
Motor Disabilities
- Large touch targets (minimum 44px × 44px)
- Reduced precision requirements for interactions
- Keyboard-accessible designs for all functions
Cognitive Disabilities
- Clear, simple layouts with reduced cognitive load
- Consistent patterns and predictable behaviors
- Multiple ways to access and understand information
Legal Considerations for Designers
While developers often focus on technical compliance, designers play a crucial role in ensuring websites meet ADA requirements:
- Courts have recognized that visual design directly impacts accessibility
- Poor design choices can create compliance issues even with perfect code
- Documentation of accessibility considerations helps demonstrate due diligence
The Accessible Design Mindset
Designing for accessibility isn't about following a checklist—it's about adopting an inclusive mindset that considers the diverse needs of all users from the beginning of the design process.
By incorporating accessibility into your design workflow, you not only reduce legal risk but create more usable, flexible, and effective designs for everyone. Remember that accessible design is simply good design—it benefits all users, not just those with disabilities.
The most successful designs are those that feel natural and intuitive for everyone, regardless of their abilities. By making accessibility a core value in your design process, you create digital experiences that truly work for all.
Additional Resources
.svg)
